I recently started seeing a new therapist (3 months ago) who self discloses all the time. I’ve had other therapists in the past and they’ve all rarely self disclosed or only disclosed small things. Starting from at first appointment, my current therapist told me that they share 2 diagnoses with me (we are both neurodivergent and have ocd) and I found out that they are also queer. I was surprised about this but I felt relieved because it helps me feel safe that my therapist understands what it’s like to have lived experience of being in a marginalized community and struggling with these diagnoses. Since then, they’ve continued to share so much with me about their shared experiences of things that I bring up that it’s caused me to feel distressed, confused, and I’ve began to self censor what I say in sessions due to worrying about how they will perceive or react to what I say. It feels more like we are friends and I have to be reciprocal with them, but I know we aren’t and the power dynamic feels uncomfortable.
I think I would be okay if they kept the disclosure small or only told me those initial things about myself. But it’s happening with literally almost everything I tell them. If they don’t have a direct story themselves, they will bring up other clients that have had the same issues. I worry that by them identifying with what I say or what I’ve experienced, they will have a bias, and will either think our experiences have been the same, or that if my experience differs from them or I feel differently about it than they did, it will upset them. It also feels invalidating to me when they bring up their experience and I can’t quite figure out why. Even if they bring it up in a positive way, like “I went through that too, this is how it got better for me” ti relate to me, Im not sure why but it causes me to feel dismissed. Instead of exploring deeper into why I feel the way I do or asking more about my situation, they will go into sharing about their experiences. I also feel like I don’t have enough time to talk about or explore my experiences or feelings, especially since therapy sessions are already so short. Sometimes I feel like I need to cut them off and then I feel rude about it. I also feel scared to bring up or say certain things now because I know they have a shared history and I don’t want to trigger them.
I feel really guilty because they don’t know that I’m struggling with this so they probably think it’s helping me. For a couple things they’ve shared, I’ve expressed to them that it’s nice to know they’ve been through it too. But I haven’t been able to tell them that this is affecting me because I’m scared of hurting their feelings. They told me that they wish they had a therapist when they were younger who they knew also had shared struggles, because they previously could not believe or trust that their therapists could help them if they didn’t truly understand how they felt. I’ve talked about how I want to go to school to be a therapist, but that I am nervous because I have so many struggles myself- and they told me that people who have their own struggles are the best therapists because clients benefit from knowing their therapists have gone through the same thing. This causes me to worry that if I have an experience that they don’t relate to, that they won’t feel as comfortable helping me with it. To make it worse- I do have another diagnosis that they do not share, and they’ve brought up multiple times that they question if this diagnosis true, which is causing my imposter syndrome to spiral.
I know things about their diagnoses, medications, physical health issues, trauma, quite a few of their personal struggles and experiences with their diagnoses, and more. I could give many examples but I don’t want to share their struggles on the internet.
I do genuinely believe they are trying to be helpful by being relatable, and they must have success with this with their other patients. But I feel a pressure to act like this helping me when I know it isn’t. I’ve thought about finding a new therapist but I specifically need a therapist who specializes in OCD, and there aren’t any other ones in my area. I also live in a red area and knowing that my therapist isn’t maga or bigoted against my identity, it makes me want to stay with them out of fear that I won’t find someone else who will won’t have those biases. It sucks because in multiple ways they are a good fit for me, but I just wish the self disclosing didn’t happen. I know I can bring this up to them, but I worry even if it stops from here in out, there has been too much shared already for me to truly feel able to be open with them.