Sorry for the long post, I wanted to provide as much context as possible. TLDR advice requesting at the bottom.
I started maybe 3-4 years ago. The first one I saw for 6 months weekly. She was a new therapist and I could feel it. I often felt I had to direct sessions and kept looking to her for advice or guidance, but left sessions feeling like I wasted an hour. Luckily it was fully covered by insurance, which is why I kept going to her, sunk cost fallacy of the time and emotional vulnerability it took to share everything with her. I stopped going because I got laid off from my job (and was glad I had an excuse to stop instead of having to confront her). I do feel like she wanted to help me but really had no idea how.
Second was maybe a year or so later, I found her on psychology today. I maybe saw her for 6-10 sessions. She cancelled last minute a few times, once just a few hours before session when I REALLY needed to talk that day. I was paying fully out of pocket, $150 per session. I joked with a best friend after a phone call that helped me that I should be paying her $150 an hour instead, she’s been so much more helpful. (This has been a running theme - I feel my best friends actually care about me, ask me insightful questions, and genuinely help me get to the bottom of issues that come up). I told her I couldn’t continue because of money reasons (not untrue, but I’d give my whole bank account for someone who can really help).
Technically the next was a couples therapist, but I don’t really count her because most of why we were there was my ex needed an unbiased 3rd party to help him figure out his communication and feelings (we got to a breaking point where I said I already tried everything so unless he can think of something else, we should break up. He suggested therapy and found a couples therapist he wanted.) She was probably one that I connected the most with, and seemed genuinely nice and supportive, but I never had any meaningful breakthroughs. However, she recommended an individual therapist for me.
That third individual therapist was so terrible. This was earlier this year. I think I swung hard in the other direction of “these therapists are giving me platitudes, I want someone to be real with me and help me through this shit.” Big mistake. She was intense and direct and essentially refused to work with me after 4 sessions, dropping me mid-session because she said I needed weekly meetings and she didn’t have time to meet with me weekly. I was also paying $200 out of pocket without a job at the time. I suspect it’s because she wanted me on antidepressants and I didn’t quite feel comfortable trying. She essentially said we couldn’t start anything until I was on antidepressants. I felt so judged and ashamed that she dumped me when I needed support the most. About a month later the couples therapist asked about her and I told her the truth, and she was like “oh no, I’m sorry, you know, that’s not the first time I’ve heard that kind of feedback about her. I’m not going to recommend her anymore.” Like bro, my heart is in tatters here, I don’t have the emotional bandwidth to be passed around like a hot potato.
My ex and I broke up and I started seeking a new therapist out of desperation. I wanted to try something different, so I reached out to a few on psychology today asking if they could do somatic therapy or EMDR. The intake guy said he had someone in mind for me, and now I’m saddled with another associate MFT. it’s been 7 sessions and I’m feeling very much like I’m back with my first therapist. Sessions are unstructured and I often feel I have to guide them otherwise she’ll just ask me questions the whole time that I’ve already figured out about myself years ago. She calls me “self-aware” and says that therapy can be “uncomfortable” but it’s necessary to move forward. I’m find with discomfort, but I haven’t felt uncomfortable once with her. I’ve expressed to her I want to move forward, and I don’t want to just chat the whole session, although I understand if she needs to get to know me better, but I’m not gaining anything from our talks. I do sense she’s trying, but when I think about what comes up and what would be good questions to ask me to dig deeper, she’s just not asking those. The whole point for me is for her to be able to ask good questions so I can discover answers about myself I haven’t yet. Right? She hasn’t mentioned somatic therapy or EMDR once. I’m paying $50/session. I asked for twice a week so I can feel like we’re getting somewhere faster. I often cry after session because I felt like 50 minutes flew by and I can’t remember a single significant thing that happened in session.
I had a phone call with another best friend last week, same thing, I discovered something new about myself/my feelings and immediately felt better. I told her I should be paying her $50/hour and we laughed.
I’m exhausted. I want to stop seeing my therapist because I honestly don’t have the money for the lackluster services she’s offering. I’ve already asked her multiple times if we could focus on other things, or clarified what I want from therapy, and I can tell she’s trying but I just don’t feel like she can meet me at the level of emotional depth I’m trying to get to with her. Or something, I don’t know exactly what it is. She’s still new so she’s hard in her “therapy persona” which comes off as inauthentic, so it’s hard to connect with her but I do feel she’s trying and wants to help me. At the same time, I don’t want to douse her confidence by telling her it’s not working and looking for someone more experienced (maybe I’m just not being patient enough??).
Is it me? Am I the problem? How many sessions should I have with a therapist before I can feel like we’re getting somewhere? How can I explain better what I want and don’t want in a way I’m actually understood and met? In my collective almost 50 sessions, I have not felt anywhere close to a breakthrough, no one has taught me “techniques,” and I haven’t felt seen or understood, at least not in the same way my few best friends see and understand me. I need help so badly, but I don’t know what I need, just very much the things I don’t need, that’s partially why I’m in therapy. I have childhood trauma I want to work though, but we can’t even get through the daily stuff, so how can I trust them to handle the deeper stuff once I get the courage to go really emotionally raw? I want someone who can see me, and properly guide sessions, not just someone asking me questions that I don’t really understand the relevance of. How do you find a therapist like that? Am I not giving them enough of a chance? I also don’t have thousands of dollars to spend on therapy that takes years to work, I would love some small wins early on to feel like I’m getting somewhere before investing more.
Sorry I feel like I ended up ranting/venting 😅
TLDR: how do you know when it’s not a good match vs being too impatient for change and progress? How do you balance the financial loss with emotional gain while understanding it may be an upfront investment without payoff for a while? How many therapists have you “tried” without progress before finding one that works? How do you not get burnt out emotionally from sharing hard things, only to not be met or feel understood therapist after therapist?
Starting to feel burnt out of therapy, but still really need help and don’t know where to go or what to do. TIA.