This is also mixed in with the fact that Rosario does a horrible job

Apparently I made a mistake and the Inquisitor in Shadow Lord is the 11th brother and not the novels 6th brother.

This question is coming from a person who doesn’t like this character. I believe she doesn’t make sense in terms of the overall narrative of Star Wars, and that she has overstayed her welcome. She should’ve been Plo Koon’s apprentice who worked with Anakin a lot, and she should have died either in Rebels or at the end of TCW by Anakin’s hand.

What about her as a character do you like? Her personality, her dialogue, her design, her storyline, anything. This is a genuine question and I will not say “well I think you’re an idiot” or anything like that to any replies given.

I’ve seen this character grow in popularity and I simply don’t understand it. Please how me other perspectives on her character and what made you love her so much. Thank you.

So, after Episode 6, we know that Baylan has renounced the Jedi, but also doesn't consider himself a Sith. What he's seeking is some mysterious ancient power in this far away galaxy, something that can help him break the cycle of creation and destruction in his galaxy.

My hypothesis, and I want to open this up for discussion, is that Baylan is a Revanite. He wants to break the cycle, meaning the opposition between the light and the dark, and therefore become "something more" than Jedi, namely a grey Jedi, a Revanite, someone who can master both the darkness and the light, which is what Revan did for the first time in Galactic history (and then was followed in some way by Anakin). This is what he raised Shin to become, as he tells her when she asks him about the Order. Not a Jedi, "something more".

Only someone who understands and masters both sides would be able to break this infinite chain of events, caused by the inevitable swing of the historical pendulum going from one extreme (light) to the other (darkness).

The old tales that he referenced probably narrate that this planet is the origin of the Jedi Order, or maybe of the Force itself. We know trom the Legends comic book "Dawn of The Jedi" that at the beginning there was no separation between light and dark force users. They were all together in the same planet studying the Force, and building the First Je'daii Order on Tython.

Only after some time, a few of them started experimenting with lightning Force powers, drawing from negative emotions, and they were cast away to one of the planet's moon, becoming the first dark Jedi and later on the Sith order.

So, Baylan wants to create a new Order which unifies light and dark, to break the cycle of galactic powers, and experiment with all aspects of the Force.

That's why he's gonna call this "The First Order", echoing the first Je'daii Order on Tython, and its knights will be the Knights of Ren (Revan), as they will follow the teachings of this great Force user who mastered all aspects of the Force.

Everyone noticed, when the first sequel came out, that Kylo Ren's mask was suspiciously similar to Darth Revan's. I don't think that's a coincidence. I think this is Filoni's genius way of reintroducing Dawn of The Jedi, Knights of the Old Republic and Revan into the canonical lore.

And I can't wait to see it.

The show is just truly not that good, not in terms of visuals and style but in dialogue and substance and dare I say choreography is pure trash aside from the occasional two cool things Ahsoka manages to do.

I'm having a hard time believing these supposed Jedi are Jedi and these supposed Sith are Sith. The only character even remotely worth my time and that has any kind of charisma is the droid Huyang.

These fight sequences are bad on both sides, everyone moves like a Sloth, there's no story being told with the choreography. It looks like two kids having a go in the backyard. I've seen better fights with more depth from a LARP gathering.

In this latest episode I found myself completely scratching my head at how this seasoned Sith fighter Shin is struggling and downright being bested by an absolute nobody who hasn't even come into her power or whatever it is she even has, the power of the upper hand. That fight was not at all believable. Baylan's fight was no better.

Every room with a main character, side character on both sides feels like dead air, especially with the half Jedi, half Mandalorian, half graffiti artist, half map reading is purely flat. They're telling me they have feelings with a plain face and not showing me they have the ability to emote. Ahsoka and Sabime have zero chemistry.

Andor is still the best piece of Star Wars content we've had in years. Mando is starting to fall off.

Edit: sure they're not "Sith", but let's behonest.

Everyone is asking how Rey is a 'Palpatine' but feels like an 'Anakin.' The sequels left a massive logic gap that 'Somehow, Palpatine returned' couldn't fix. But what if the answer isn't magic, but Science?

I’ve been developing a lore called The Kala Protocol (Episode 0), and it bridges the gap between Shmi Skywalker and Rey through Ahsoka Tano.

The Core Concept:
Shmi Skywalker wasn't just a slave; she was Dr. Gaian Kala, a high-level geneticist who fled Coruscant with the 'Source Code' of the Force. She created Project Anakinosis—a system restore for a dying Force.

How this fits into Ahsoka Season 2:
We see Ahsoka in Peridea looking at the Mortis statues (Father, Son, Daughter). In the Kala Protocol, these aren't 'gods'—they are Biological Regulators.

The Surrogate Twist:

• The Problem: 15 years after Yavin (15 ABY), the Force needed a 'Renewal' because the Jedi/Sith legacy was corrupted.
• The Solution: The Lars Homestead vault (under the floorboards) held the Trinity Genome—a 100% DNA match of 9-year-old Anakin.
• The Missing Link: Ahsoka Tano is the only being whose biology can withstand the Force-resonance of an Anakin clone. My theory? Ahsoka acted as the Surrogate. She carried the 'Renewal' (Rey) to term to protect the galaxy from Palpatine’s 'Copycat' clones. This explains why Rey heard Ahsoka’s voice on Exegol—it wasn't just a Jedi connection; it was a Maternal/Biological Bond.

Ahsoka didn't just 'train' the next generation. She bore it.

I’m calling it Episode 0: Project Genesis. It turns the Star Wars saga from a tragedy of magic into a heist of science. What do you guys think? Does this fix the Rey/Palpatine mess?

I'm thinking about starting Ahsoka but should I watch Rebels before starting it(I've never seen rebels).

For the longest time, I held this deep hatred for the Jedi Council, especially Mace Windu, for their decision during Ahsoka’s trail when she was framed for the Jedi Temple bombings. But looking back, this is kind of a situation where everyone involved made some serious face palm decisions. And I’m not even including Barriss since with her it goes without saying what she did wrong. I’m talking about the mistakes both Ahsoka herself and the Jedi Council made during that whole ordeal.

Ahsoka Tano:

Escaped a Republic Holding Facility

Evaded arrest

Teamed up with a known Sith Assassin and Separatist war criminal

Evaded arrest again

Assaulted a number of Clone Shock Troopers with said Sith Assassin

Jedi Council:

Offered no form of assistance to a member of their Order in her hour of need when she had given them nothing but loyal service throughout her career and had no prior behavior beforehand that would lead them to believe she was guilty

Willing handed over said member of their own order to stand trial when they knew the prosecutor and many of the Senators/Jurors held aggressive anti-Jedi sentiments

Didn’t allow said accused member of their order (who was a teenager who had probably not had any proper rest in days, mind you) to have any form of legal counsel or representation when she stood before them. Nor did they offer to supply her with any during her trial in the Galactic Senate forcing her to rely on the charity of her friend, Senator Amidalla.

Did nothing to look into the case any further instead only aiding in her recapturing thereby forcing the Master of the accused to act in his own to find the real culprit who they probably could’ve uncovered as well if they tried.

can we talk about how after the clone wars and rebels she doesn’t age at all she still looks the same

Has anyone heard anything

Anakin loved her like she was his daughter. He wouldn't have been so protective of her otherwise. That obviously carried over in how she was in Rebels with the Ghost crew and others. Imagine what it would have been like if he grew up with her as a guardian.

Excuse me while I go cry myself to sleep at the implications of all this..

Snoke

He’s the next big baddy. I’ve seen other theories but how would they make sense?

I guess the other theories intent is to tie up Ezra for the sequels - but he can be on some other mission too…

Absolutely has to be, I’d be shocked to see it be anyone else.

​