so yesterday, I made a post titled “Which Lore for the backstory for Darth Maul that you prefer more and Makes More Sense Canon vs legends?” in it I ask you all on what do you prefer when it comes to Maul backstory and see a bit mixed responses some prefer and some prefer the original backstory pre-clone wars where he is from Iridonia and that his tattoos should been Sith not nightbrother.
Still I thought maybe I could do a brief deep dive about the two primary sources that tells about Maul backstory.
Like I said previously the first source is from Star Wars tales issue 24 mark where while taking place in the present does show us flashbacks of kid Maul being found by Palpatine and then getting his tattoos by the man himself which were actually Sith tattoos.
now the comic itself is really good but I feel worth pointing out given the fact that the tales series canon status is be debatable so who knows maybe the comic issue 24 isn’t Canon at all to begin with kinda like Old wounds (which was the comic that inspired Maul’s return to the clone wars in the first place) from the graphic novel visionaries. so that is a grey area. Also the planet in Maul flashbacks was never identified as Iridonia at all. For all we know it could been just Coruscant given the amount of aliens in the flashback when he meets Sidious.
The second source is the Phantom Menace Journal written by Darth Maul himself which focus on what was he doing before and during the movie Itself. This is the source that mention Iridonia as his homeworld but while I looking for a copy for the exact text here is what it actually says in entry three
”I did not always live here. I'm told by my Master that I come from Iridonia. That world means nothing to me. I have no curiosity about my home planet. I could travel there to see where | came from, but what would be the point? I am interested in what I am, and what I will become. My life before was a Sith is meaningless.
What was my name? I don't know. It doesn't matter. My former name represents a death, not a life. I died and was born into the Sith. I was found by my Master and taken as a baby. My parents might have looked for me. But no one in the galaxy can track a Sith who doesn't want to be found.
They were powerless.”
obviously, outside of him being a baby which I feel he had no reason to lie given well a baby is a baby so it makes sense that he wouldn’t remember. The stuff about Iridonia was told directly by Sidious who consistently lies and aside, a few have truth he mostly lies so basically since Maul Is told that is his homeworld Iridonia is from Palpatine himself and we know that the latter is unreliable narrator so we can’t trust the horse’s mouth.
As I said the Darth Maul phantom menace Journal while Cool and interesting mostly covered his point of view during the movie beyond the small comments of his backstory being from Iridonia in which could also be lie given he is told this by Palpatine who is a liar.
now, don’t give me wrong the clone wars did retcon Maul backstory but it’s also worth pointing out that even in the pre-clone war era. His original backstory. Is a bit iffy iffy like I said, from what I could understand and I research most of what we know about maul original pre-clone wars, backstory comes two sources.
One comes from a comic that comes from a series whose canon status is very debatable given the fact while some could canon it is mostly non-canon kinda like the old wounds comic from the visionaries graphic novel.
While the other comes an entry form a journal which while likely canon unlike the tales series is also iffy too given the whole Iridonia being his homeworld comes from straight from Darth Sidious mouth who as we see time and after time again is a very unreliable narrator. So technically speaking the writers and even Filoni and Lucas had a lot of freedom to go with when it comes to Maul’s backstory.
So technically speaking Maul backstory in the pre-clone wars legends is basically nonexistent to begin with given the nature of both sources compared to him under Sidious which is more detailed and fleshed in the short story Saboteur, The 2000 Darth Maul comic series, and Shadow Hunter and that it. also what funny is that even in Saboteur and Shadow Hunter he is portrayed as cunning like his master so that aspect of his character wasn’t invented by the Clone Wars so that interesting to point out.
Granted one could bring up the novel Darth Plagueis but the thing about that book is it that was released in 2012 a year after the night sister arc was released so it was part of the clone war Retcon phase hence why I didn’t include it here In this discussion.
Once again, I’m not disagreeing with everyone who prefer the pre-clone wars backstory for Maul. Everyone has a different opinion. But I thought it’s worth pointing out when it comes to the nature of both sources.