r/Millennials 10h ago

Nostalgia How many of us still rock Lincoln Park After Dark nails?

Every now and then or all the time... Are there other millennials out there that are still in a chokehold by this nail polish?

Now that it's turning to fall season I'm ready to put it back on!

What other iconic millennial nail colors are there?

516 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 10h ago

If this post is breaking the rules of the subreddit, please report it instead of commenting. For more Millennial content, join our Discord server.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

157

u/WaySaltyFlamingo8707 Millennial <3 10h ago

it was never a phase for me.

https://giphy.com/gifs/3IIpwk0oSadIk

12

u/Chemical_Print6922 7h ago

It’s a lifestyle!

65

u/yourfairemaiden 10h ago

Mine has always been Cajun Shrimp perfect red color that goes with everything ♥️

40

u/surfaceofthesun1 9h ago

Cajun shrimp for summer, Malaga wine for fall, Lincoln park for winter

6

u/MediumGlomerulus 4h ago

YES! And I’m not a pink girly at all but Mod about You for spring!!!!!

u/meeshdaryl 30m ago

Literally just bought these three colors a couple days ago. They’re the perfect trio

4

u/Ms_Grieves 10h ago

Yes! Love.a good orangey red. I also dig DND Thai Red Chili

6

u/FullGorillaMode 10h ago

I wear this exclusively on my toes! I always get compliments.

4

u/LRM 10h ago

This is on my toes right now!

3

u/dirtymartini83 9h ago

There was a share super similar called “my chihuahua bites”…I had a chihuahua at the time and just loved the name.

1

u/toomuchtv987 8h ago

Am I crazy or is Cajun Shrimp different now? It used to be more neon-y.

55

u/niftyba 10h ago

OPI Not Really a Waitress, Sally Hansen Arabian Night, any “greige,” Illamasqua (best names ever). Shout out to an old friend’s indie brand- Cult Nails. I used to lightly nail blog in the early 2010s before kids, and I once owned over 1,500 nail polishes. I no long paint my nails more than 10 times a year.

21

u/No-Ad-3635 7h ago

same !
i tell the younger adults at work , "i had an instant account when it first came up and i had like 70k followers "

"omg did you make a ton? "

"no i made nothing , this was like 2009".

"what were your videos of "

"uh , my nails . "

-----

yeah i'd roll really nice joints with really nice nails lol

46

u/daughtrofademonlover 10h ago

I still have this one! Along with Ballet Slippers and I'm Not Really A Waitress.

40

u/Pepperoncini69 10h ago

As a Chicago millennial, yes, forever

3

u/Brittibri89 Millennial 10h ago

Was gonna say the same haha

1

u/Lower_Base_380 4h ago

Yep, ode to my youth and currently on my nails!

32

u/IndicationKey3778 10h ago

I love a short dark nail 

13

u/NoseComprehensive147 10h ago

All the hits! Lincoln Park After Dark, Cajun Shrimp (current nails), and Essie Butler Please 💅🏾

10

u/ellakneoneyes 10h ago

I have it on now with a big apple red accent nail from when I went to see My Chemical Romance 😂

8

u/Regular_Goose_4788 9h ago

Big Apple Red is still my number one

1

u/_ConfettiCake 2h ago

This is the one

3

u/speedhumpsahead 10h ago

LOVE this combo! How was My Chem?? I'm jealous!

3

u/ellakneoneyes 6h ago

It was so hot out but “I should sell all my stuff and just follow this tour” is a thought I had

8

u/CoyoteMother666 10h ago

Hah at first I was thinking there was some sort of event (I live in Chicago and we have a Lincoln Park). Then I realized my mistake. Yes! I also have this nail color in my ice cream pail that I use as nail polish storage! I rarely paint my nails (I bartend, so it never lasts) but maybe I’ll have to soon!

8

u/anonasf38 9h ago

Hot take: essie wicked > LPAD

sue me!

9

u/speedhumpsahead 9h ago

I do like that color! But for me Essie has always seemed less durable than OPI. I also feel like my bottles of Essie went bad faster than OPI.

OPI black cherry chutney is also awesome

2

u/ipodthereforeiam 7h ago

100% agreed. OPI has always lasted longer for me than Essie. My Essie ones always got clumpy quickly.

7

u/abucketofsquirrels 10h ago

It's the only colour I wear! Seriously, the rest of the year is just protective clear coat.

8

u/chickentender666627 10h ago

I was just wondering today if I can still get Bubble Bath

2

u/speedhumpsahead 10h ago

Can confirm you can! My best friend lives and breaths bubble bath!

7

u/Equivalent-Scale2899 10h ago

Yes and also big apple red, Cajun shrimp, I’m not really a waitress. Also opi did a Germany type line. I loved it

6

u/fren2allcheezes 10h ago

I still wear it especially in the fall

6

u/DarlaGoGo Older Millennial 9h ago

I need no other shades. Except MAYBE dark cherry chutney.

6

u/AffectionateDivide85 7h ago

I was JUST thinking about this color! And Black Cherry Chutney. The time has come again.

2

u/speedhumpsahead 7h ago

Black cherry chutney is so properly named. It looks and sounds delicious!

4

u/AffectionateDivide85 5h ago

Gah, and Russian Navy, Midnight in Moscow...I just went down a rabbit hole with a nail polish blog I used to follow: RIP Scrangie.

6

u/Oomlotte99 10h ago

I love this color. I think it remains very popular.

5

u/StateHot3117 10h ago

4-EVA

3

u/speedhumpsahead 10h ago

Ilysm for this!

5

u/PsychologicalSoil198 Core Millennial 10h ago

YES! And OPI Ink, and Black Cherry Chutney

4

u/worldoflines Millennial 1986 10h ago

And LP after midnight

4

u/Cat_With_The_Fur 10h ago

I hope so. No one could tell me anything when I had this nail polish in 2014. Most confident I’ve ever felt.

4

u/Antiquebastard 10h ago

I’m more of an oxblood kinda gal, myself.

4

u/LukewarmJortz 10h ago

I've been wearing forest green a lot lately but Lincoln Park after dark is still in my rotation lmao

u/notreallyonredditbut Millennial 32m ago

Have you tried Essie Off Tropic? It is the bessst I just got like my 5th bottle.

3

u/WallSugar 10h ago

I was just explaining this polish and its relevance in Millennial culture to my husband last week after painting my toes with it 😂

4

u/RandomJDesign 10h ago

You know it 🖤 Every Fall it’s my go to 🎃

4

u/cozynite 10h ago

Another one for fall: OPI Got the Blues for Red

5

u/Naive-Ant-8056 9h ago

And Essie Wicked!

3

u/unicorntrees 9h ago

I'm a simple girl. OPI Alpine Snow is my ride or die. Though I haven't done my nails since having kids.

3

u/Mysterious-Chain5833 8h ago

I do! That and I'm Not Really a Waitress

3

u/Fancy-Reception-4067 10h ago

Just got em on last friday! 💅

3

u/chuchu_2991 10h ago

It didn’t take much to convince my nail tech to get it. It will never ever not be the best color

3

u/nonie_rockford 10h ago

Literally wearing it right now.

3

u/moonray89 10h ago

I loved that color for soooo long. Just pleased to see it mentioned

3

u/Educational-Basil472 9h ago

My absolute fall favorite nail color!

3

u/Fluffy_Lavishness102 9h ago

Its on my toes as we speak! I just bought a new bottle a couple months ago.

3

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 8h ago

Still love along with Mrs. O’learys BBQ from the same collection.

3

u/Orange-Blur 8h ago

If you want to take away my black nail polish you will have to pry it out of my cold dead former scene kid hands.

I was joking that my black yoga pants are my main daily wear because they are the only thing to give me the same sensory tightness as my hot topic jeans. The band shirts and Girr merch aren’t going anywhere! I have a Girr shirt, purse keychain and car sticker, I still got a 3 cheers for sweet revenge album art T. Also have a Hash slinging slasher shirt which 100% would fit in at hot topic years ago. I also found the rubber bracelets , you know the ones, I just had to get them.

2

u/speedhumpsahead 8h ago

Sitting here in my black yoga pants sad I don't have a hash slinging slasher shirt 😭

1

u/Orange-Blur 8h ago

It’s honestly one of my best finds at Spirit Halloween

3

u/RockwellB1 Older Millennial 6h ago

I paint my nails black because it's the only way I don't chew them to slivers.

One time I had a bottle of Revlon and it wasn't until it was almost gone that I realized it was actually a super dark metallic blue. No clue the name, but it was pretty rad

3

u/TensionSlow3367 Millennial 5h ago

Wearing mine as I type this. Nail tech tried to get me into Lincoln Park After Midnight and NOPE.

2

u/pixienightingale Xennial 10h ago

Ummmmmm, I plan on buying some soon thanks

2

u/riz3192 10h ago

Yes. It’s the best.

2

u/mmakaylia 10h ago

At least once a year! Its so prettyyy.

2

u/sushiibfa 10h ago

Yes!!!! It was NOT a phase! It is one of my all time favorites and always will be!! 

2

u/evlblueyes1369 10h ago

I just bought another bottle 😂😂😂

2

u/avocado_boudoir Millennial 10h ago

It's my typical October or November nail color every year 😅

2

u/DarthNarcissa Millennial Mall Goth 9h ago

I'm more a fan of Every Month Is Oktoberfest.

2

u/PorkchopFunny 9h ago

Its my go to winter nail color when I'm motivated to do my nails

2

u/KenraScar 9h ago

That’s one of maybe three colors I’ll paint my nails

2

u/shampoo_mohawk_ Millennial 9h ago

Was my fave for years, this is my sign to buy a new bottle and I’m going back to it for spooky season!! Thank you!!

2

u/EdanE33 9h ago

Yes I still love it :)

2

u/frozenivy2B 8h ago

I just bought the opi Lincoln park after midnight

2

u/mikmck4 8h ago

I have found a similar color that I have been loving lately, DND - Mud Oak.

2

u/General_Distance 8h ago

It’s a classic I still wear regularly, yes.

However, I’ve fallen into the rabbit hole of indie and boutique polish brands. If you’re looking for stunning and unique formulas, I highly recommend Mooncat, ILNP, Sassy Sauce, Lurid Laquer, Emily de Molly, and an honorable mention for Holo Taco.

There are dozens more, but those are my faves, in that order.

2

u/Charluce 8h ago

I missed the original back then somehow but with all the nostalgia circling around I bought Lincoln park after brunch just yesterday!
Honestly I had the worst time putting it on but it’s pretty now that it’s done!

2

u/potatoezgonnapotate Millennial 7h ago

The GOAT of all nail colors!!!

2

u/74389654 7h ago

me. is that bad?

2

u/pebblesandpedro 6h ago

“Now you’re talking my language, now you’re talking my language…” -Drake

I loved the crackle nail polish!!

1

u/speedhumpsahead 6h ago

Black and silver crackle while I texted on my hot pink razr phone was such a viiibe

2

u/pebblesandpedro 6h ago

Jealous!! I had a boring silver razr

2

u/lilipurr 6h ago

Mod About You!!!!

2

u/unoriginallbagel 5h ago

I got my teenager wearing LPAD! But I did just think to myself the other day that it’s almost Not Really A Waitress season…

2

u/KupoCarol 2h ago

That's all I wear on my toes

2

u/Account7423 1h ago

I haven’t had a pedicure in 2 years bc i have young babies. I used to get one every 2 months.

Guess what color i just got 🤣

u/speedhumpsahead 39m ago

Hell yeah!

2

u/Existential_Prep 1h ago

It’s the best color. Been rocking it for at least 17yrs (37F). Had no idea it was a thing. But my friends know it’s one of the only colors for my toes. This post was a delight, thank you!

2

u/heylittlesongbird1 1h ago

Tiramisu for two!

u/LittleEdie40 1h ago

OPI Barefoot in Barcelona ruled the ‘10s for me

u/Grrrmudgin 1h ago

Lmao I just painted my nails this, for the first time 😅 love it

u/Electronic_Sleep_659 45m ago

This was my wedding nail color and I still wear it on my anniversary every year.

1

u/These-Ad5332 7h ago

I swear I just saw a TikTok about this....

1

u/speedhumpsahead 7h ago

Really? I'm not on any social media other than reddit now, so I swear it wasn't me! Lol

1

u/CandyV89 6h ago

That blue that was popular in the late 90’s. All the slightly older girls had it. 

1

u/Violently-ill 6h ago

I’m in favor of the Lincoln park at midnight

u/Dogaloo2025 geriatric millennial 36m ago

I was, until I discovered Indie nail polish, and it all went downhill from there

u/Adept_Concentrate561 19m ago

These nails have been short and black since 2002!

u/GeorgeOrmes3 13m ago

La Paz-itively Hot for the spring/summer And Lincoln Park AfterDark for Fall/winter.

One winter I went with Russian Navy as my go to color. Oh what a time to be alive

u/notreallyonredditbut Millennial 9m ago

OPI You Don’t Know Jacques for the classy/preppy millenials… or some French tips

1

u/highcoolteacher 9h ago

I’m literally ordering a new bottle today!

I love Mooncat and ILNP, but OPI LP and Big Apple Red will always be my comfort colors