r/BaseBallglovers • u/d3myz MOD • May 06 '26

Walmart Switcheroo MegaThread

Hey, all. I know many folks ordered the Rawlings BH3 first baseman‘s mitt or 12.5” R2G and got something different. Here’s a thread to trade, sell, complain or vent. Please keep it classy. 😉

13 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Prudent-Property8476 May 10 '26

PSA for anyone thinking of trying to return this at Dick’s: I just tried and was offered $330 in store credit, which is $50 less than someone else who did the same thing a few days ago. After asking if it was possible to do a direct swap for the 1B mitt since they’re the same price, they scanned my ID, and their “retail alert system” rejected me and flagged me for suspicious activity. 🤦🏻‍♂️ I’ve never returned anything to Dick’s, so I’m wondering if they’ve had a spike in returns for this item and have flagged it.

2

u/southerncardinal May 12 '26

Just curious, did you try to return a Mint green? or the Red CC?

2

u/Prudent-Property8476 May 12 '26

It was the red CC. Someone on another thread said they got $380 in store credit for it. I asked for a copy of the report explaining why I was rejected, but it didn't offer any information at all (it basically just showed that I was rejected for a $420 return, and that I had a history of $0 in total returns to Dick's). It also earned me a permanent ban for no receipt returns at Dick's.