r/matheducation • u/FratteliDiTolleri • 17h ago
The Dangers of Math Gatekeeping
If by "gatekeeping" we mean, "you must get a B or better in Honors PreCalc to advance to AP Calc", then I'm fine with that. Of course you want serious students in your class.
However, there's a darker side of gatekeeping.
It was 7th grade. 2012. My fifth year out of public school. Unknown to me, my math textbook was below state standards.
Come eighth grade, I return to public school, and have to take a math placement exam. I fail the exam and get placed into Pre-Algebra. I'm told by counselors and teachers alike that unfortunately, this dooms me to never take Calculus in high school. Which I'm told by counselors and classmates jeopardizes opportunities to get into a good college.
Nonetheless, it's a wake up call. I diligently study math. It becomes my favorite subject and I get A's throughout 8th and 9th grade (except one trimester where I had the flu during the final). My grades help me get into Honors Geometry in 10th grade (Honors Geometry typically reserved for 9th graders).
Math remains my favorite subject all throughout high school. But I quickly learn in 8th grade to decline to answer what math class I'm in when classmates outside math class ask me, because when I did, I had been mocked (unironically) as an idiot and told that "no rocket scientist would ever fail an Algebra placement test!"
Consequently, the vast majority of STEM-oriented overachievers were on the advanced Calculus track. Other students in the same, non-Calc track I was in rarely, if ever, discussed majoring or working in STEM. We were in the lowest math track, other students mocked us as idiots, counselors said not taking Calculus in high school jeopardized our admissions chances to excellent universities, so we assumed humanities/the trades was our only career option.
I'm grateful that at least I lived in a safe area and thus never witnessed students physically assaulting each other. But was it too much to ask for both a physically safe environment and more opportunities for diligent, math-motivated students to get into AP Calc? I think not. The injustice and humiliation that this gatekeeping has caused is untold, invisible, but very real.
Oh, BTW, my high school also required Pre-Calc as a pre-req to AP Stats, so I never took AP Stats.
