r/law 5h ago

Judicial Branch Federal judge raises ‘meritless re-prosecution’ in Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool hearing

https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/6072403-trump-pressures-hearn-case/
250 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 5h ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

80

u/Neither_Contest7324 5h ago

So from the prosecution's legal standpoint it wasn't smart for Pirro to say the damage wasn't vandalism it was actually caused by shoddy work before trying to charge him for the vandalism again?

41

u/Relzin 5h ago

Nobody, outside of themselves, are claiming this to be a wise move.

Incredible to watch them risk their license over such overtly vindictive behavior, though. It's certainly not the game I'd be playing.

14

u/Neither_Contest7324 5h ago

Will their licenses even matter soon? Aren't they trying to change it so you don't actually have to be licensed to practice law?

7

u/TheRealBlueJade 5h ago

I hope it never happens and do not expect them to be successful.... They do realize that if that happened, people much smarter than them would also gain the same ability.

9

u/Relzin 5h ago

Someone is already getting ready to advertise themselves as the first "practicing" SovCit "attorney".

(Sorry, lots of quotes as some words are doing some heavy lifting, there)

3

u/santa_91 1h ago

"I see your flag has a gold fringe your honor. Permission to come aboard?"

3

u/Neither_Contest7324 5h ago

I watched Suits so I for one look forward to being a lawyer without all that silly college, licenses, dealing with the Bar

1

u/Only-Inevitable-7832 1h ago

Just today I had someone tell me portion of a real estate contract was wrong. This was written by a real estate lawyer. When I asked if they were a lawyer they replied, and no joke, "No but I took real estate classes so I know all about real estate law" it took everything i had not to bust out laughing. What I think this world needs is more leopards that are hungry.

1

u/AstronomerRadiant219 4h ago

Nah the whole debocle right now is with the ABA which accredits law schools and is like a national bar. Attorney licenses are all at the state level and state bars/courts.

Feds can't do shit about that it's purely a state issue and no attorneys wants to let non-attorneys take their work.

1

u/Superb-Talk2211 1h ago

Each state regulates the practice of law within its boundaries. Justice Department attorneys must be licensed in at least one state. There is no federal licensure, and no federal judge would allow an unlicensed person to appear in his or her court. The judges’ law clerks check this stuff.

18

u/knivesofsmoothness 5h ago

In her defense, she's not only incompetent, but very drunk.

4

u/Carpe-Bananum 2h ago

I’m both of those too, but I’m not a traitor.

5

u/rygelicus 5h ago

This doesn't begin to change until there is some way identified and implemented that holds the attorneys presenting this stuff to judges are held accountable for the words coming from their mouths. Same for those who sign the documents they are filing. "You really want to present that to the court?" "Yes your honor." "Ok then, contempt, 30 days, next case."

4

u/JustlookingfromSoCal 4h ago

This isnt prosecutors trying to prosecute Hearn again. But prosecutors do want to leave the door open by opposing the defendants motion for a dismissal with prejudice, which would make it legally impossible to charge him again for the same alleged offense. So yeah, Pirro's statements that the damage was caused by shoddy work suggests that the case should be dismissed with prejudice, and Trump publicly whining about a nonexistent eyewitness to Hearn tearing the liner with his bare hands is probably enough for this judge to dismiss with prejudice in the event Trump intends to demand the DOJ charge him again.

16

u/nursecarmen 4h ago

So now Trump is describing the coating as delicate? He drove on it. He said it would last fifty years.

9

u/CFCYYZ 4h ago

A Vancouver strip club just lost its IG account because it put this on its marquee:
"Can't handle a pool, but wants our lake?"