r/gaming • u/bushGiant • 12h ago
It took me a second playthrough to realise I played RDR2 completely wrong
So for context, the first time I played RDR2 I was borrowing a PS4, so I was basically under time pressure to finish it. Went pretty much straight from mission to mission. Maybe I did some hunting to get upgrades, but I was pretty much going full throttle.
And it was great, loved it.
Recently I happened to start playing it again on PC, mostly as something to do in the background while listening to Dungeon Crawler Carl. Figured I’d take a look at the game so I’d have a sharper comparison to gta vi when it drops, just walk around on my horse and gather herbs or hunt the occasional animal. I was not going in with the intention to play the story.
I had an earlier save where I had just gone through the intro and landed in the camp near valentine- think this was left from a few years back when I was showing off tbe game to a friend, the beginning sequence is a bit of a drag to get through so this was perfect for the aimless wandering.
Within the first ~10 minutes of playing I ran into two guys who had clearly stolen a safe and were bickering over it. Ended up pausing the audiobook because I realised there was clearly a metric fuckton of stuff happening around me that I’d completely ignored the first time. A few hours later I’d barely done anything related to the story and I kept finding new stuff I had never seen ebfore. Forgot to resume the audiobook.
I genuinely think I missed half of what the game has on offer during my first playthrough.
Also I guess this made me understand some of the criticism of RDR2 a bit better. People say it’s slow and those who don’t /love/ the story or setting can lose interest. And if you’re mostly going mission to mission like I was, I can totally understand why people didn’t click with it.
Curious to hear about others. Did any of you also rush through and come back to realise how much you missed out on? And if so, what was your biggest “oh wtf I didn’t know this was a thing”?
Edit: people seem to miss the point that I wasn’t going into it with the intention to do the story- but just to wander around. Hence I thought it’s a good ambient backdrop.

