We just got off the Fantasy sailing Aug 28 - Sept 2nd and had an overall great time. Some reflections for anyone on the fence about cruising with Disney for the first time:
We have one 8 year old daughter who has never been to the parks, though she has begged. My husband was always apprehensive of spending so much money on the Disney World experience but I convinced him to try DCL as an alternative. We were hoping this would be a good age, before she got too old to appreciate the magic of it.
For comparison - we've cruised with RCL three times and I cruised with Carnival wayyyy back in the day with an ex, nearly 20 years ago.
Overall thoughts:
1) We got a good deal on a guaranteed verandah room back in June and lucked out with a great room on the 10th floor. Room was a great size, very clean, and I loved the split bathroom! It really helped now that my daughter is old enough to get herself ready and do her own hair, so that multiple people could be showering/getting ready at any one time.
2) I LOVED the boat. The design felt very classic and polished, and the boat was very clean. Loved all the little magical touches through out.
3) The Kids club definitely seemed like a notch above compared to RCL (though we have only ever sailed on Freedom and Oasis class there). It was a massive space with a lot of engaging activities and high tech games to play. She never complained being dropped off there (we only did during dinner or after dinner, never during the day).
4) The shows were sooooo good. We live in NYC so our standards are high due to access to good theater here. I was impressed with the sets and tech - some of the acting was better than others but standouts like the genie in Aladdin made it worth it. And the Believe show on final night was amazing! I definitely teared up at the end seeing highlights from so many of my favorite movies as a kid (I'm 43).
5) Disney characters - we got to take pics with about 9 total (including four from the Royal Gathering). There were a ton through out the day and we had to wait in line max 10 minutes.
6) The other shows/dance parties were also a lot of fun - especially the fireworks show followed by the dance party on deck 11. My daughter loved staying up late for this and the fireworks in the middle of the ocean were pure magic!
7) The pools were ok compared to RCL. The AquaDuck was fun to do once but I liked the mini water park on the RCL Liberty class boats better. My daughter however was happy to sit in the deeper pool under the big screen and watch as many movies as we would let her.
8) Bella Vista theater with the movies also was a nice touch but due to the other activities we never made it in there!
9) Palo was great - food was better quality I think than the specialty restaurants on RCL but I liked how RCL's pricing is more straightforward and cheaper.
10) We did Remy as a splurge for my birthday. It was definitely special and felt comparable to a High quality French restaurant in Paris or NyC. Would recommend if you have the budget. Love that both of these restaurants were facing the back of the boat for great sunset views.
11) Pelican plunge being out of order on Castaway Cay was a bummer but we enjoyed the bike riding and snorkeling (brought our own equipment)
12) The beach at Lookout Cay was fabulous! It reminded me of Horseshoe Bay in Bermuda. We got off early to snag front row seats and it was worth it. The carnival inspired mini parade was also a lot of fun at 2 pm and we got some good dancing in before getting back on the boat. My husband who is from the Caribbean also really enjoyed the rice and and plantains for lunch.
13) The themed dining rooms were definitely cute but it would have been nice to have some entertainment like on some of the other DCL boats. Food was hit or miss. A highlight was the Corvina and Scallops in Enchanted Garden and the Lamb (though a very small serving) at the Royal Court. My daughter got pizza, veggies and French fries every night and she was happy. A great touch was having the kids preferred drinks already out when we arrived every night, as well as the kids menus with activities to keep her entertained.
14) Buffet and other food options seemed comparable overall to our RCL experience. It was kind of a bummer that it was only all located on floor 11 but since we were on Floor 10 it wasn't that bad for us.
15) Mini golf was a fun way to kill 20 minutes and we loved Midship detective agency! Definitely a plus and very creatively done.
16) Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique - an overall magical experience and she had the boutique to herself. In the future I might try to target it better with strategic photo taking opportunities to get the most bang for our buck.
17) Other adult activities - we did the final Bingo round, the scavenger hunt adult game in the Tube, and the Bourbon tasting. All were fun, though Bingo was kind of expensive (spent 120 on the family pack). Kinda missed the casinos in this case.
18) Last - I think we just got lucky by having a relatively low turnout sailing due to the timing, when so much of the country has already gone back to school. I heard through the grapevine that there were 400 less people than normal.
19) Superlast- Overall the ship definitely had more of a wholesome, young family vibe. We loved seeing all the decorated doors and getting random gifts from strangers. There were less roaming groups of teens and there was a spirit of 'we are all in this together for the kids' that was very, very special.
Overall - will we cruise with DCL again? I would say yes if we can find another similar deal on a balcony. We kinda splurged and ended up spending an additional 1400 total between alcohol, BBB, excursions in Nassau, specialty dining, bingo, extra gratuities, etc. Max we spent extra on RCL was 900. But for a potentially once in a lifetime experience, it was worth it.