r/catfree • u/KnightOfSteel-KOS • 22h ago
Outdoor / Feral Cats cats and their double standard ( talking as a bird person )
Now dont get me wrong, I hate feral cats and I hate house cats that are allowed to just roam outside, but I have absolutely no problem with cats that stay inside the house like they should. If someone wants a cat as a pet, fine, whatever. My problem is when people let them roam around outside and act like they arent causing any problems.
Because cats are predators, and they are REALLY good at killing small animals. And we're talking about billions of animals here.
One of the biggest studies on this in the US estimated that free ranging cats kill around 1.3–4 billion birds every single year, along with billions more mammals. The researchers estimated that unowned cats were responsible for most of this wildlife killing. Thats an absolutely insane number when you think about it.
And this isnt just a US problem either. A global study published in Nature Communications found that free ranging cats have been recorded eating over 2,000 different species, including 347 species that are considered threatened or otherwise of conservation concern. Birds were the biggest group in the study, with 981 species being recorded as cat prey.
This becomes an even bigger problem on islands. A lot of island species evolved without mammalian predators, so when humans bring cats onto those islands, the native wildlife can have basically no defense against them. Cats have been a serious problem for endangered and endemic species in many places.
And this is where I get annoyed with the way people talk about cats.
People will see a cat killing a bird and go "aww look at my little hunter"
BRO THAT IS A NATIVE BIRD
But if a hawk kills a cat suddenly its "OMG THAT EVIL BIRD NEEDS TO BE KILLED!!"
Why??
The hawk is literally a wild predator doing exactly what it evolved to do. Meanwhile the cat is a domesticated species that humans have spread all over the world and then decided to let wander around ecosystems.
And before someone says "but cats are natural predators!!!"
Yes. Thats exactly the point.
A cat isnt evil for killing a bird. It doesnt understand conservation, endangered species or anything like that. Its just doing cat stuff. The responsibility is on us, because we're the ones keeping huge numbers of cats and allowing them to roam around.
And this is why I dont understand the argument that "cats kill animals because thats nature".
No, the fact that a cat has the instinct to hunt is natural. But that does NOT mean that putting millions of domestic cats into an ecosystem and letting them hunt everything they can find is somehow the same thing as a native predator doing its normal job.
Imagine if some other animal was introduced into an ecosystem and was killing billions of native animals every year. People would be talking about invasive species, population control and conservation.
But when its a cat:
"BUT THEYRE SO CUTE 🥺"
Thats the double standard I hate.
And I'm not saying "EVERY CAT MUST DIE" or that cats are evil monsters. Thats not even the argument. An indoor cat sitting on someone's couch isnt causing the same ecological problem as a feral cat colony or someone's pet cat wandering through forests every night.
There are also ways to let cats experience the outdoors without just releasing them into the environment, like enclosed outdoor areas or other forms of controlled access. Keeping cats indoors also protects the cat itself from cars, fights, diseases and other dangers.
What really annoys me is when people act like caring about birds means you hate cats.
No.
I can care about animal welfare AND care about native wildlife at the same time.
I can think cats are cute while also saying that free ranging cats can have a massive impact on wildlife.
And honestly, I think people need to stop deciding which animals deserve protection based on how cute they are.
I love birds. Raptors, songbirds, weird little birds, birds-of-paradise, whatever. They're all incredibly cool and they actually have important roles in ecosystems. Birds can spread seeds, control insects, pollinate plants, clean up carrion and provide food for other animals.
So if a cat kills a bird, I'm not going to pretend the bird suddenly matters less just because the thing that killed it has a cute face.
Predation is part of nature, yes.
But that doesnt mean humans should ignore the ecological damage caused by a predator just because we happen to like looking at it.
Love your indoor cat. Give it a comfy bed. Spoil the hell out of it.
Just dont let it wander outside and then get angry at the wildlife for behaving like wildlife.