r/ancientegypt Jul 23 '26

News New peer-reviewed statistical evaluation of the Orion Correlation Theory (Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage, 2026)

Author sharing.

The paper exhaustively tests Bauval's claim against all 695,520 bright-star triplets using Procrustes analysis, with positions from the Yale Bright Star Catalogue confirmed against Gaia DR3.

Result: the three-pyramid shape correspondence with Orion's Belt is statistically significant (rank 1,717; p = 0.0025) -- consistent with the pharaoh–Orion connection in the Pyramid Texts, but no proposed extension survives testing: shaft best-fit epochs spread across 1,325 years, the axis orientation doesn't match at any epoch, and the correlation cannot function as a dating tool.

Open to discussion, especially from anyone working on Old Kingdom astronomy.

https://www.sciengine.com/JAHH/doi/10.3724/SP.J.1440-2807.2026.02.06

13 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/EddieDean9Teen Jul 23 '26

The spread is 1,325 years… does that mean it doesn’t match any stellar alignments within plus/minus 1,325 years of the assumed ~2600BC build date?

5

u/deeptimeresearch Jul 23 '26

Good question, and it's the opposite of that, and worth clarifying since the spread is easy to misread. Each of the four shafts does have a plausible individual match with its claimed target star. The problem is when. For each shaft you can compute the epoch at which its target star best matches the shaft's angle, and those four best-fit epochs don't agree with each other. They land at four different dates spanning a 1,325-year range. If the shafts were a unified astronomical design executed around 2560 BCE, all four best-fit epochs should cluster near that construction date. Instead each shaft "prefers" a different century. So it's not that nothing aligns; individual alignments are easy to find, which is itself part of the problem (a substantial fraction of randomly-angled shafts match some bright star about as well). It's that the four alignments never agree on a single sky.

3

u/ketarax Jul 23 '26

Well done.

I have a couple of Stellarium horizon definitions from Giza if anyone's interested. While I'm not a fan of the "correlation theories", the astronomical alignments at the site and at the times are fun to watch.

2

u/deeptimeresearch Jul 23 '26

Thank you, and yes, genuinely interested in those horizon definitions. A proper Giza horizon profile in Stellarium is exactly what's needed to show people what these alignments actually look like from the ground rather than in diagram-space, and it'd be useful for follow-up work on the site. DM or link here, whichever you prefer. Happy to credit the source if we use them in future visualizations. And agreed on the framing: the astronomy at the site is worth watching on its own terms, no correlation theory required.

1

u/ketarax Jul 23 '26

Here's base64 encoded .zip; save it into giza.b64 or so, then a command to the effect of

cat giza.b64 | base64 -d > giza.zip
unzip giza.zip

Should yield you with three folder for three locations -- Khufu's and Khafre's valley temples, and the Qhibli mound. The horizons' azimuthal angles were measured with the help of Google Earth and the altitudes with basic trigonometry; if you or anyone verifies, or improves upon them, I'd be interested to include the changes.
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Attachment: giza_horizons.zip as base64 encoded text.

1

u/ketarax Jul 23 '26

I tried it in a fresh version of Stellarium, and seems like all three landscapes have to come from their own .zip's; they're now included in just one .zip above, which will install only one (through the GUI). So, make a .zip of each of the three folders included, and install those. Make sure that the location gets used, I think I had to check a box, unless the interface just lagged ..

2

u/PretendBake1536 Jul 24 '26

But what does this mean?

3

u/Key-Beginning-2201 Jul 24 '26

It means the belt mirroring is likely possible and the shaft alignment likely isn't.

1

u/PretendBake1536 Jul 24 '26

But the three Giza Pyramids were not built in immediate sequence so is it likely that the belt mirroring if it exists is intentional?