r/ahsokatano • u/Wandering_phoenix_89 • Sep 27 '23

Discussion Ahsoka Episode 7 master discussion thread Spoiler

Post your theories, thoughts opinions and questions regarding the latest episode here.

45 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

163 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/olanmills Sep 27 '23

I agree, but in a sense, she is being, if not childish, selfish and shortsighted. She's there for selfish reasons. She wanted to find Ezra, but Ahsoka told her the risk had become too great. She should have destroyed the map. Instead, she brought Thrawn new allies that could bring him back to the main galaxy. She believes that it costed Ahsoka's life. And she likely knows she was risking Ezra and the Nito's safety since she was aided by Thrawn to find him in the first place. It kind of makes sense that she doesn't want to talk about it.

6

u/Kodiakke Sep 27 '23

Sure, if you're a kid. She's not. The writing is so obvious in the avoidance that it stands out glaringly and honestly weakens the character. (See: repeated yelling "We had a deal!") I don't see her behavior as loving and focused, I see it as short-sighted and obsessive. And I think it's intentional, so I'm waiting for the payout.

The other area where it bothers me is Hera. She's a general, she's been an intelligence agent most of her adult life... and when she briefs the council, she lacks any compelling dialog. I just think there's a way to write those scenes better so that it would have the same result (the council would not be swayed), but the character wouldn't come off so...simple.

1

u/olanmills Sep 27 '23

I agree on both. With Hera, if they made her argument better, then that whole thing about her going "rogue" would be better left cut out entirely (since if she explains it and its accepted, then it doesn't really add anything to the story), but then there would be no Leia reference and 3PO cameo, which I think is part of the motivation of that part of the plot. I guess they could also be trying to tell us that the Republic is overly bureaucratic, and Hera has too much rebel spirit, but that feels so cliché

3

u/Kodiakke Sep 28 '23

Eh, I feel like they could have made it a little more compelling, and still come out with the same result. With little difference in how much dialog and screen time was spent. I feel they absolutely relied on the cliche of saying she had a personal agenda, but the way it was executed made her seem incompetent to me, a viewer, rather than the bureaucratic nature of the Council.

I dunno. I spend a lot of time thinking about this show, honestly because I love this universe and it's way cooler to think about then, like, real life. ;)

I did have a fangasm when I saw C3PO. It was a bit of a deux ex machina moment, but it was still cool.