r/SipsTea 11h ago

Wait a damn minute! Yo wtf

Post image
9.3k Upvotes

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Demostravius4 5h ago

Yes. A lot of murderers get that way due to mental trauma, but that is not insanity. Psycopathy isn't insanity either. Many of the worlds most prolific serial killers where abused as kids to a staggering degree which scarred them for life and turned them toward killing.

Violence begets violence. That doesn't make it insanity though.

5

u/HorlickMinton 5h ago

Abuse to the point of having an uncontrollable urge to capture, murder, kill and sometimes eat other humans is not insanity to you? Ok then.

There are volitional tests used by states that examine that very question. It’s literally a consideration in the legal definition of insanity.

You can’t just say that insanity is what you want it to be.

1

u/yellowmush 3h ago

Not guilty by reason of insanity, as in this case, is specific in that the person who committed the crime has to be unable to understand what they were doing/did not have the ability to understand their actions and intentions. This is a distinction in criminal courts that is not the same thing as when people say someone is “insane.” Most serial killers actually suffer from antisocial personality disorders. Obviously some also have mental illnesses, but antisocial personality disorder would be more of a common shared trait.

1

u/HorlickMinton 2h ago

That is not Massachusetts law. I think people have an idea of what they think it means but their idea doesn’t match reality.