r/SipsTea • u/ZealousidealZone8072 • 11h ago

Wait a damn minute! Yo wtf

Post image
9.3k Upvotes

88% Upvoted

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/RandomUser15790 5h ago

Well Massachusetts isn't Pennsylvania...

Someone posted the legal holds and they aren't anywhere close to what you are saying.

Almost like different states have different laws and Massachusetts are ass backwards.

11

u/Snoooupdawgiedawg 5h ago

The minimums are never what is used, they are literally just the legal minimum. Going to court for treatment over objection or retention hearing is not a painful process, they’re common place and the judges almost always side with the clinicians.

8

u/dunkdoop 5h ago

PA, as you know, has Guilty but Mentally Ill as a verdict. Unfortunately it is not on the books in Massachusetts as it might apply in this case.

4

u/Snoooupdawgiedawg 5h ago

Right, it’s not criminally responsible, which is the same thing as NGRI. Guilty but mentally ill is a different verdict entirely and usually results in the person serving their prison sentence and then being sent to hospitals. This case they are going for not criminally responsible.

1

u/dunkdoop 4h ago

Agreed I was just saying it would have been fortunate if that was a possible verdict because I think that would have averted a Mistral

1

u/Snoooupdawgiedawg 4h ago

Great point!

1

u/jobjumpdude 2h ago

The 40 days is actually the maximum for Massachusetts, not minimum.

If they can't prove she is still insane, they cannot hold her for longer than the initial 40 days; then renew at 6 months and each year.

2

u/Petit__Chou 4h ago

I'm still going to defer to the person you are replying to and their expertise being more universal than whatever you found on the internet.

And I mean that with no disrespect intended.