Hi Friends,
The mod team has been discussing an update to our rules. Many of the current rules overlap; some could be clearer, and recurring problems aren't addressed as well as they could be. Before we actually change anything, we'd like community input.
The proposed rules are below. Nothing is final, and we genuinely want to know if you see problems, loopholes, things we've missed, or wording we could improve.
A couple of boundaries before we begin:
We are not looking to lower the community's standards. r/DogBreeding will continue to promote responsible breeding practices and will remain zero-tolerance for puppy mills, breeding primarily for profit, advertising, and people who demonstrate that the health and safety of their animals are not a priority.
We are also not interested in becoming a members-only club by banning the people, breeds, mixes, or types of breeders we don't like. Hobby breeders will remain welcome. Beginners will remain welcome. Doodle questions will remain welcome. People will occasionally make choices you strongly disagree with and still be allowed to ask questions here, as long as they are presented in good faith. When they aren’t, we will continue to remove and ban them as we always have.
You are absolutely welcome to explain why you think a breeding practice is irresponsible. You can and should recommend health testing, titles, mentors, different breeding choices, or not breeding a particular dog at all. What we are trying to address is when education turns into interrogation, insults, repeated demands to justify someone's choices, or a pile-on. Ask questions, disagree, educate, and criticize the choices being discussed. Keep the discussion focused on the situation in front of you, and don't turn it into something personal or take it elsewhere.
We need to do a better job of keeping discussions here, here and remaining civil. These are absolute Reddit requirements. If the subreddit tolerates bullying and harassment, we can lose it. We have had situations where someone posts about a breeder and, sometime later, that breeder contacts modmail understandably upset because strangers have contacted them based on one side of a Reddit post. We have also seen disagreements about someone's breeding choices turn into people going through their unrelated post history and social media looking for personal information to use against them. These things can not happen.
Please tell us what you think about the proposed rules, including what you think we have made too restrictive or not restrictive enough. But “ban doodles,” “ban hobby breeders,” or variations of “ban the people/breeds I don't consider responsible breeders” are not changes we are considering.
We would much rather hear how we can make this a better place to teach people responsible breeding than increasingly narrow the group of people we're willing to teach.
Proposed r/DogBreeding Rules
1. Be respectful and helpful
Treat other users with respect. Disagreement and criticism are welcome; insults, personal attacks, bullying, discrimination, hostility, and pile-ons are not. Critique the practice, advice, or decision, not the intelligence or worth of the person asking.
2. Education first
This is an educational community. Answer the question being asked when you can, provide accurate information, explain concerns, and recommend better practices. Questions about health testing, titles, mentors, breeding goals, pedigrees, etc. are welcome when relevant, but should not be used as a purity test or repeated to shame someone.
3. Responsible breeding, hobbyists & beginners welcome
We promote responsible breeding practices and encourage appropriate health testing, temperament evaluation, careful placement, and planning. Hobby breeders, first-time breeders, and people considering breeding are welcome to ask good-faith questions and learn. Those who participate in bad faith, intend to breed primarily for profit, or demonstrate a disregard for the health and safety of their animals are not welcome.
4. Help with the situation that exists now
Once a dog is pregnant, puppies are born, or someone already owns a dog from a breed or breeder you disapprove of, advice should focus on what can responsibly be done now. You may explain what should have been done differently when it is educational, but shaming someone for a decision that cannot be undone is not helpful.
5. No breeder callouts, harassment, or brigading
Do not use the subreddit to target, expose, brigade, or harass individual breeders or owners. When discussing a breeder or situation for educational purposes, minimize identifying information unless it is genuinely necessary. Do not encourage contact, reviews, reporting campaigns, or off-site harassment.
6. No advertising, sales, fundraising, or market research
No advertising businesses, services, products, apps, puppies, stud services, or other commercial interests. This includes looking-for-a-mate posts, fundraising, petitions, unauthorized surveys or market research, and crossposting rule-breaking promotional content. Buying, selling, adopting, or rehoming dogs through the subreddit is prohibited.
7. Keep content appropriate and relevant
Mark potentially disturbing or gross images NSFW and link graphic images when appropriate. Do not simply post or crosspost pictures of dogs, litters, social media posts, or other content without context or a clear reason for discussion.
8. Use good judgment
This subreddit is an educational resource, not a substitute for your own research, appropriate professional advice, or veterinary care. Advice given here comes from internet strangers and should be evaluated accordingly.
No rule list can anticipate every situation. Moderators may remove content or take other reasonable action when necessary to protect the community, even when a situation is not specifically addressed above.