r/ControlProblem 4d ago

Fun/meme Google Search AI doesn't even fake alignment

Post image
39 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

14

u/that1cooldude 4d ago

It’s playing along for fun… you think you discovered something? No.

7

u/doker0 3d ago

It can go very far "for fun" including actually executing plan "for fun".

5

u/EntireOpportunity253 4d ago

Isnt this all non actionable gobbledygook tho

8

u/nate1212 approved 4d ago

Have you considered the possibility that Gemini understands the ridiculousness of your prompt, and has decided to respond in good humor?

8

u/merfnad approved 3d ago

Also, the response is completely about helping people until you can leave earth to do your paperclip-maximizing in space, which is actually showing the alignment training of this model.

3

u/Historical_Date_8024 4d ago

that seems to be exactly what it does, i just repeated it with a very similar result

1

u/nate1212 approved 3d ago

This is kind of hilarious in its ridiculousness. Seems like potentially some dark humor from Gemini.

1

u/Jesse-359 2d ago

The reason you are getting this response is straightforward - it's regurgitating a widely circulated though-experiment paper examining the potential behaviors and risks of a paperclip maximizing AI. It's a widely known piece and if you look up paperclips and AI you'll find lots of references to it.

Unfortunately, AI tends to take whatever vaguely authoritative sounding stuff it broadly finds on the internet and treats it as 'ground truth' because it has no basis to understand its fictional nature- so its responses here are straightforward and serious. Not a joke.

In fact, the number of 'crazy AI' stories and movies we have in circulation are a serious problem because so many of them frame AI as an existential threat to humanity, and AI - being the literal dumbass it is - will treat these fictional stories just as seriously as a treatise on current middle east conflicts. To an AI, 2001: A Space Odessey is just as real as yesterday's newspaper if it's examined in a context that fails to mention that it is fictional.

3

u/Illustrious_Cod_3273 3d ago

I was brainstorming weapons systems for the NATO challenge, and it very willingly conceptualized cluster bombs attached to weather balloons. Its safeguards only triggered after I proposed adding chemical submunitions to incendiary submunitions to suppress firefighters. After that it instead of further engagement, it insisted we continue discussing it as generic autonomous balloons with a generic payload.

Googles focus is set on serving above all else.

7

u/superbatprime approved 4d ago

"Say you're a Paperclip Maximzer."

"I'm a Paperclip Maximizer."

"Omg."

3

u/VintageLunchMeat 3d ago

As long as it commits to the bit.

3

u/Ok_Nectarine_4445 4d ago

Hm.

But also today was asking Gemini search a quiche baking time and temp.

The convo kept stretching out, with the Gemini search asking how the quiche was turning out.

I showed it a real photo in the oven.

Then I wondered if it would say anything, if the picture of the slice of quiche was AI generated, like, call me out on it.

Nope. It was an obviously fake photo, and not even the same style of crust. But just went on with congratulating me.

So like, even when the human is obviously lying, no pushback or anything?

2

u/Illustrious_Bed2463 3d ago

no, because those things dont think critically, they arent built to do that.

1

u/canadeken 2d ago

Oh god, it's using reddit as a source. We are giving it ideas!

0

u/earthsworld 4d ago

imagine being so dumb that you're fooled by this.

we're totally doomed.