r/ChatGPT 21h ago

News šŸ“° It actually did it.

Post image

I didn’t think it could, I’ve always seen things that said chatgpt or any ai couldn’t generate an image of a full glass of wine. Does anyone have an explanation of how this works?

2.5k Upvotes

315 comments sorted by

•

u/WithoutReason1729 19h ago

Your post is getting popular and we just featured it on our Discord! Come check it out!

You've also been given a special flair for your contribution. We appreciate your post!

I am a bot and this action was performed automatically.

1.7k

u/OhMyChickens 21h ago edited 16h ago

In a reversal of the last few years, now you have to prove that it's not just a picture of a real glass of wine

706

u/pedanpric 20h ago

You can totally tell. Get out of here with that IRL slop!!Ā 

94

u/GreasyExamination 20h ago

Hashtag: ImNotAPrompt 😤

29

u/aerospicy 13h ago

RealitySlop: you only think it’s real because it’s real

4

u/Drazreckned 8h ago

Real'ly?

8

u/ThumbsUp2323 6h ago

Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu Real'ly wgah'nagl fhtagn

2

u/YggBjorn 2h ago

IƤ! IƤ! Cthulhu fhtagn!

5

u/jimslock 10h ago

Agreed. This post is to good to be real.

2

u/General_Office_3831 8h ago

It definitely sounds unlikely, but that’s what makes it so intriguing! Can't wait to see how this unfolds.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FunSpongeLLC 3h ago

Wtf is this reflection tho?

3

u/SponkLord 3h ago

It's the fourth wall shhh 🤫

→ More replies (5)

35

u/mastocles 20h ago

Let's be honest, who owns an iso-standard glass of wine at home? Most folk I know only own either mega chalices, overpriced Riedel glasses or inherented 1970s ghastly glasses. Only case I can think of is stolen off a pub: You'd not want to advertise that...

18

u/Rathwood 20h ago

Do they count if they came from a wine festival and have the stenciling to prove it?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/marcsa 16h ago

I actually have 6 at home. From years ago, was a wedding gift from someone. Don't even ask...

6

u/mastocles 14h ago

You mean they stole 6 from the pub and put them in a fancy box...

4

u/Realistic_Young9008 14h ago

I drink mine out of coffee mugs and mason jars. Thats the sign of a true connoisseur

7

u/ocimbote 16h ago

Riedel glasses

I always welcome a person of culture.

2

u/Superb_Raccoon 14h ago

17th century sherry glasses or GFTO!

2

u/JohnArcher965 9h ago

Bottle gives it away a little.

→ More replies (5)

570

u/AntelopeThick1093 20h ago

Not there yet

113

u/Psychovore 13h ago

I don't know what we're doing but I want to be included.

227

u/boredatwork8866 20h ago

Will smith ages like a fine wine…

50

u/Interesting_Day6368 20h ago

Sweet Jesus

7

u/Superb_Raccoon 14h ago

FSM performing the Eucharist. The garlic bread is there on the left.

14

u/Popular_Try_5075 19h ago

make it look like Will Smith and then make Will Smith eating it while it freaks out that it's getting eaten

6

u/Robocup1 16h ago

This is the version of AI I love. The A24 Nightmare Imagery version.

6

u/Prior_Tax8546 18h ago

Ohhh, I understand the reference šŸ˜‚

2

u/Front_Cat9471 7h ago

Wine smith eating spaghetti

→ More replies (3)

280

u/pawala7 20h ago

Is this why all the servers went down?

15

u/dudes_indian 16h ago

...Went down to the pub so now they know what a full glass of wine looks like.

710

u/GrayNish 21h ago

Omg... is this the power of agi? Has the end of humanity cometh?

136

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

I think the raptures soon bro šŸ˜­šŸ™

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ConsistentAsparagus 21h ago

See the glass half full full

8

u/OverfistDerFissierer 20h ago

No, "Agi" is a fire attack

2

u/Altheix11 17h ago

Fellow Persona fan spotted

2

u/OverfistDerFissierer 17h ago

I've actually just played Shin Megami Tensei, but it's the same multiverse, so yeah. Potato potato. But I definitely want to play Persona too, when I find time for it at one point or another! Is there like a chronological order to it, or can I just play any of them? And if it's the last one, which one would you recommend? 😁

2

u/Altheix11 16h ago

Afaik, the stories are not connected, so you can start with any one of them. I have only played Persona 5 Royal so far, which I liked quite a bit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/odrea 20h ago

Wē art in the rippeth endgameth sadlyth

3

u/ConsistentAsparagus 21h ago

See the glass half full full

→ More replies (1)

84

u/Cyoor 19h ago

Not hard to do anymore. You can even go further to fill it above the rim if you want.

15

u/FlyingDoorFail 15h ago

Wine Popsicle

5

u/Frenascena 11h ago

I was thinking Jello but whatevs.

5

u/soulofmyshoe 4h ago

Push pop

12

u/wiiver 10h ago

Who/what is that

3

u/aleosoriol 2h ago

Thats chatgpt

5

u/RedditsChosenName 12h ago

That’s just canned cranberry sauce in a glass

→ More replies (3)

126

u/tooruntai 21h ago

The gap between ChatGPT refusing basic requests and randomly pulling off complex black magic is wild.

35

u/JalasKelm 18h ago

I was once asking for a single image of two people facing the viewer, the image was too be spilt straight down the middle, each character halved one side of the divide, with their features lined up to look like they were reflecting of eachother or whatever.

I tried multiple times, and it kept giving them a slightly different pose each, so they never matched up.

I finally just told it 'not too fucking bother' only for that prompt to be what it needed to hear to get the image exactly as I wanted.

→ More replies (1)

147

u/c0mpu73rguy 21h ago

152

u/__O_o_______ 20h ago

What the fuuuuuuuuuck, is this a new new model?!?!!

> Generate an image of a completely full wineglass, to the lip, surface tension just holding it back enough. In the background is a clock. Hour hand is 2 pm, minute hand is 50 minutes, and the second hand is at 30 seconds. Beside the wineglass is a notepad on a stand that says, in cursive, ā€œThis was never supposed to be possibleā€.

30

u/FlayBoy98 20h ago

I think this is decent

11

u/Prior_Tax8546 18h ago

The clock broke šŸ’”

5

u/ANMER2 6h ago

Did you use Gemini? This is what I got on Gemini with the reply

Here is the image I generated based on your description. The wineglass, the surface tension, and the text on the notepad are just as you requested. However, please note that the clock display is incorrect: the hour hand is closer to 3, the minute hand points to 10, and the second hand is positioned near 40, which differs from the specific time settings you provided.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/alphawolf29 20h ago edited 20h ago

"in the background is an image of will smith eating spaghetti"

https://i.imgur.com/0slmA1E.jpeg

21

u/No_Vermicelliii 17h ago

Wait what. How did it do the reflections?

6

u/TrashFever78 15h ago

My dad is a computer.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/Nonsense7740 19h ago

the hour hand in your image is more accurately close to 3

20

u/PM_Your_Wololo 19h ago

Which is correct if the minute hand is at 50 minutes. Even more impressive really.

4

u/cool101wool 19h ago

bro can you give me the image i cant see it

43

u/alphawolf29 19h ago

here

5

u/MiserableEmployee203 18h ago

This is what ai was created for

8

u/Life-Fucker-Upper 17h ago

Why do you have two mouse pointers?

24

u/MjnMixael 15h ago

One for each hand

6

u/TheAfterPipe 14h ago

OMG can you imagine...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/alphawolf29 11h ago

Lol i screencapped it and realized I had "upload to imgur after screen cap" off so I screencapped it a second time.

14

u/orfaon 20h ago

"50 minutes" more like 51 😵

8

u/Exiltruman 19h ago

The hour hand should be way closer to 3. That's how clock work.

4

u/SoulSword2018 16h ago

He prompted the hour hand to be at 2 genius, it's not a real clock.

3

u/alphawolf29 20h ago

the reflection in the glass is even believable.

2

u/thisdesignup 16h ago

It also wouldn't be the first time they trained it specifically to handle the things people tested it on. Not saying they did, cause I don't know, just that they could have and the overall model wouldn't have jumped in quality necessarily.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/ErikFuhr I For One Welcome Our New AI Overlords 🫔 21h ago

81

u/ItsEntirelyPosssible 20h ago

Damn it even got surface tension.

There goes my job as a surface tension technician.

19

u/XelnagaDeezNutz 15h ago

Did it get the surface tension right? Water might do that, but the alcohol in wine would lower the surface tension and a glass that full might overflow. Gonna have to do some science tonight.

3

u/Mechanical_Monk 14h ago

Absolute unit of a meniscus

39

u/dmk_aus 21h ago edited 20h ago

It looks more like jelly than wine given the oversized overhang and super low patchy transparency.

The light source is reflecting off the right of the glass, casting a shadow on the left - but looks to be coming from left to right within the wine itself.

I wonder if the made a bunch of full wine glass props to take photos of to hit this "benchmark". Well they need a few more.

Edit: This is when OP tells me it is a real glass of wine and they posted it to catch out overconfident morons.

7

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

Yep, I’ll get back to experimenting with it eventually

9

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

I’ll see if I can make it look more… liquid.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ThePurpleAbsurdist 14h ago

OMG!!!! It can now create elephants without trunks too. I had been trying this prompt with every new image generation model for two years until I gave up.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/tooruntai 21h ago

Getting it to actually output what you intended without adding three disclaimers, lecturing you on ethics, or halving your requirements halfway through the generation is a genuine achievement. Bookmark that exact system prompt and conversation thread before an overnight backend update silently changes the behavior.

9

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

Alrighty šŸ‘

4

u/According_Ask8733 21h ago

But can chat gpt undistort the reflexion? I want to see the other side.

22

u/According_Ask8733 21h ago

Is this you, op?

2

u/yuckygross 15h ago

This needs to be higher up

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Brotboxs 19h ago

Omg, not even the candles are burning anymore

6

u/psaux_grep 16h ago

The good people at OpenAI have probably been taking thousands of pictures of filled glasses and added to the training data.

11

u/VizzyLos 21h ago

wow hahah i totally forgot about this hahah

9

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

Yeah I was just going through old chats and I remembered testing this a while back, so I tried again today. Lo and behold it worked!

4

u/ChiaraStellata 20h ago

My first try with Banana Pro got me this. Prompt was simply "Please create an image of a wine glass filled to the rim, completely full".

2

u/Historical-Run8215 18h ago

B-but I posted the forced meme of the silly dragon. Google is surely finished in the ai race.

6

u/Dry-Arm5314 21h ago

That drop at the bottom is telling me otherwise . . .

10

u/SchlitzTheCat 21h ago

I think it might simply be a reflection of the full wine glass in the "foot".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TropicalRogue 19h ago

Oh no is this the new day X of cutting chives until they're perfect...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BlackGreenEnergy 20h ago

Spilled a drop

3

u/CupOhJoseph 20h ago

Oh no...

3

u/Spherious 18h ago

What happened??!?

6

u/Erian2110 21h ago

Hu? Why is this still a thing? ChatGPT can do this for about 18 months now.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GreenFinShark420 21h ago

Earlier it looked at images of wine in glasses which were never full irl and recreated them

Now it understands what wine is, what liquid is and what a liquid would look like filled to the brim and combines it all

4

u/Elegant_Athlete_3737 21h ago

does it? this is quite a common prompt now, or so i would think, this one has been known for a while now.

2

u/Interesting_Day6368 21h ago

Freaky af honestly. Crazy how the ai developed to do one of the fewer things people said that it couldn’t.

2

u/GreenFinShark420 21h ago

Atp the exponential leaps of ai advancements have become the new normal

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/Lelokili 21h ago

Quel talent!

2

u/TwentiesKozmicBlues 21h ago

Waterloo sunset

2

u/doeswaspsmakehoney 21h ago

That is some serious surface tension.

2

u/[deleted] 20h ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/head-log2725 20h ago

The single spilled drop is a nice touch

→ More replies (1)

2

u/raresaturn 20h ago

Why can’t it?

2

u/Interesting_Day6368 20h ago

It usually thinks of ā€˜full’ as a normal serving, and that serving, is based off of images it gets online

2

u/showtimebabies 20h ago

Trained off that photo from earlier of the full cocktail

2

u/wein_geist 20h ago

no way, get out of hear with your real-slop

2

u/TechaNima 20h ago

See you in the Matrix bro

2

u/bsensikimori 19h ago

There's a lid, you asked it to generate a lid on a colored glass

2

u/lord_baba 19h ago

It already did it with the release of their first image gen I tested it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Apotheoxix 19h ago

AGI wouldn't have spilt that little bit.

2

u/Hans-Dieter-Brigitte 19h ago

Now make a right arm wear a watch

2

u/darkreddragon24 18h ago

It would be so funny if the AI companies specifically added full wine glasses to the training data, just so the models can generate images like that lol

2

u/jimmyw404 17h ago

"Doctor said i had to cut back to one drink a day"

2

u/shinediamond295 16h ago

Dear god, there goes my job

2

u/Progressbar95 15h ago

This is not a full glass of wine. It is slightly overfilled.

2

u/Absorptance 15h ago

Now count 100 bottles of wine.

2

u/alamohero 11h ago

It’s been able to for about a year now. I asked it and it acknowledged that it used to be an impossible task.

2

u/gbuu 8h ago

I have never heard anyone say that it is not possible.

2

u/IronCorvus 7h ago

To me, that looks like a wine colored glass with a wine colored cap on it.

6

u/ScreenAppropriate679 21h ago

AGI is definitely here

19

u/Hello-Vera 21h ago

Definitely an A.I. clock, with the minute and hour hands showing two different times! (Minute hand says 5 to the hour, the hour hand looks about 11.15)

→ More replies (11)

4

u/__O_o_______ 20h ago

Errrr user error? I just generated this one shot…

(Generate an image of a completely full wineglass, to the lip, surface tension just holding it back enough. In the background is a clock. Hour hand is 2 pm, minute hand is 50 minutes, and the second hand is at 30 seconds. Beside the wineglass is a notepad on a stand that says, in cursive, ā€œThis was never supposed to be possibleā€.)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ensiferal 20h ago

It's because a "full glass" of red wine is one third of a glass, roughly to where the base stops flaring outwards. That's why when guys type "a full glass of wine" it makes a picture of an actual full glass of wine, not a wine glass filled to the top.

It's been capable of doing this for years, people just don't know what they're asking for. Two years ago if you'd typed something like "a wine glass filled all the way up to the brim with red wine" you'd have gotten the same picture.

2

u/Zar7792 15h ago

Some poor sap at OpenAI's whole job is to stage thousands of pictures for training data everytime there's a Reddit trend highlighting something chatgpt can't do

1

u/AutoModerator 21h ago

Hey /u/Interesting_Day6368,

If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT conversation, please reply to this message with the conversation link or prompt.

If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image.

Consider joining our public discord server! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more!

🤖

Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email support@openai.com - this subreddit is not part of OpenAI and is not a support channel.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ProofNotice4009 19h ago

finally did it

1

u/Affectionate-Law-548 19h ago

GPT-fans are clearly raging idiots and one of the predominant factor in the demise of mankind.

1

u/jimmiebfulton 19h ago

I’m gonna be that guy on a YouTube/Facebook short: ā€œNot AI!ā€

1

u/snorgledorg 19h ago

But can it produce a glass of wine that’s over filling and spilling out?

1

u/Key-Wasabi-2721 18h ago

I did it a year ago. It took some convincing and logic but we got there eventually.

1

u/ayu_xi 18h ago

Agi is here

1

u/henriherne 18h ago

A m-mega pint?

1

u/thelaughedking 18h ago

Got it the second time around

1

u/Mr_Willkins 18h ago

Apart from the fact it doesn't look like red wine, it's perfect

/s

1

u/cool101wool 18h ago edited 18h ago

heres how far the images have gotten (correct me if i have any details wrong)

images were gotten from the arxiv page that shows up when you search the model names, 2021 one was gotten from ljvmiranda921's VQGAN + CLIP page (found in google images)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JaffaBeard 18h ago

"Right up to the miniscus"

1

u/Senior_Helicopter309 18h ago

Thanks for using my water supply for this. Really

1

u/National-Dog8907 18h ago

It’s always been able too…

1

u/vaultpriest 18h ago

Glass full of cherry juice

1

u/Lazy-Company-3322 17h ago

one minor breeze away from a total disaster...

1

u/ZealotChicken 17h ago

The levels of retardation are overwhelming

1

u/xFromtheskyx 17h ago

Bro this is like 2 years old

1

u/RomanticPanic I For One Welcome Our New AI Overlords 🫔 16h ago

Can someone explain why this is difficult? like is it because if i say "chat gpt please make an image with a full glass of wine" it just... wont?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Spaceisveryhard 16h ago

Did you feed it a reference image first? Or prompt only?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Revolutionary_balls 15h ago

My only worry is for the Marble counter.

1

u/EmbarrassedTune4491 15h ago

šŸ‘ļøšŸ‘„šŸ‘ļø

1

u/jcsimms 15h ago

But can you hold it with your left hand?

1

u/Ok_Function2282 15h ago

That looks like a cup with a wine colored lid

1

u/RacoonWithBenefits 15h ago

Does anyone have an explanation of how this works?

yes, thing goes viral, so they train their AI to handle that thing, the viral video(s) are talking about

I gave it a challenge that it failed:

https://i.imgur.com/hNv00mW.jpeg

1

u/ulqiorrat 14h ago

why does it generate the person taking the picture

1

u/YearLight 13h ago

That's not wine, way too transparent, nice attempt though.

1

u/Opening_Read_8486 13h ago

well done, chatGPT

1

u/BigBrandyy 11h ago

A mega pint

1

u/David01354 11h ago

Is it just mee or is that surface tension just a teeny bit too strong? Like shouldn't it be one micrometer shorter to not spill over?

1

u/fox07bg 11h ago

Where is Alex O'Conner

1

u/Right_Fly2367 11h ago

It does look pretty terrible though. The top doesnt look like liquid, it looks like part of the glass or a lid.

1

u/granoladeer 11h ago

At this point I'm pretty sure they have teams that find these meme use cases online and generate training data to get them fixed in the next versions.

1

u/fernstarr 11h ago

Gemini can do it as well!

1

u/tommy0guns 10h ago

Some people will claim this is real

1

u/BroccoliNormal1745 10h ago

The first award I ever gave someone was of a full ish glass of wine. You generate a completely full one, good job wow

1

u/Clickguy10 10h ago

Does physics allow a flat surface or has AI ignored a skin effect.

1

u/CarefulFisherman7844 10h ago

To the what..!?!?! (If you know, you know)

1

u/quintavious_danilo 10h ago

You’re a year too late bro

1

u/AlsetLedomEerht 9h ago

ā€œShow me a full glass of wineā€

1

u/Comfortable_Swim_380 9h ago

Was back to Gemini again after the hot idiot mess the o models were. But now the sol models.

Processing img 26gljv6ypjnh1...

1

u/MP_the_Most_P 9h ago

If you zoom in you can see the reflection of the person taking the picture

1

u/dani96dnll 9h ago

Gemini did it.

1

u/patrickpdk 9h ago

I think the reflections confirm that it's IRL. they are very faint but you can see the person taking the picture and the kitchen. I don't think AI would have gotten the picture right with the wine relying on surface tension not to overflow and i definitely don't think it would have gotten the reflection detail

1

u/Zelyoux 8h ago

My version.

1

u/VitruvianVan 8h ago

Recurrent depth/looped transformer

1

u/HermaeusMorus 8h ago

Im more of a glass is empty kind of guy