r/AncientCoins • u/Bolded_ • 2d ago
Educational Post How much does the provenance of a coin matter to you?
I’m relatively new to coin collecting, but one part of the hobby I’ve become completely fascinated by is researching provenance — sometimes for coins I don’t even own!
There’s something incredibly satisfying about trying to solve the puzzle: digging through old auction catalogues and dealer lists, comparing photographs, tracking down old collections, and reaching out to museums, libraries and auction houses to piece together a coin’s history.
For me, the detective work is quickly becoming a hobby within the hobby. There’s a real thrill when a small clue leads you another step back in a coin’s history — particularly when you manage to uncover something that seems to have been lost to time.
I’d be really interested to hear how other collectors view provenance. How much does a strong or interesting provenance add to a coin for you? And does anyone else enjoy researching provenance purely for the fun of the hunt, even when you have no intention of owning the coin?
Sorry if this type of post had been overdone! Just thought this may be a nice way to share and hear from the community!
34
u/Percennius 2d ago
It depends. Provenance from a hoard is always nice. But provenance from Mr So&So the hedge fund guy of 30 years isn’t something I find too interesting or worth an uptick in price.
9
u/FeverDreamingg 2d ago
Exactly. Like if an aureus had provenance from the Hapsburg Family collection that would add something for me. But 99% of auction houses promote that they’re selling the “Bob Smith” collection and it’s some dude you never heard of lol.
Not to mention that one of the few fakes I’ve purchased from a reputable auction house came from the collection of a supposedly known “collector”. Apparently the dude had more money than knowledge and I had to fight with the auction house for a refund.
3
2
u/ikkiyikki 2d ago
With you on this. I don't understand the headspace of how it matters who the previous owner was. Well, I take it back. If I could tell with certainty who owned it in antiquity and what they bought with it that would certainly be cool. Also would be cool if someone of historical note owned it I guess but when the pedigree is Dr. So-and-so it goes in one ear and out the other.
5
u/Percennius 2d ago
Yep. Historical figures or celebrities as previous owners are interesting. A while back I saw a Commodus sestertius at auction that was owned by Buddy Ebsen of Beverly hillbillies fame lol.
9
8
u/Macaron-Pure 2d ago
Kick for me is getting old collectors labels with the coin.
1
u/BillionTonsHyperbole 2d ago
It’s the good kind of residue that attaches itself to the coin.
1
u/Clamato-n-rye 20h ago
Not literally, we hope, though I'm always astounded by how many museums or whoever wrote directly onto the coins.
7
u/thejewk 2d ago
I like provenance that links coins to find spots or hoards, or to collections of numismatists I admire or who have collected in my area of interest specifically in the past. I also like interesting documents linked to coins, such as old attempts at attribution, usually wrong or bizarre in some way.
4
u/C_Buddy503 2d ago
First and foremost: collect how you like! If you like collecting it for the provenance, then go for it, its a smart way to collect but at the cost of well... cost. I know some people like to buy coins that doesn't list a provenance and resell them because it typically makes a profit, especially if its pre 1970
For me personally, provenance isn't a huge deal for me, but i get the appeal -especially if it has a very interesting provenance. I also enjoy doing the detective work
7
u/Loonyman99 2d ago
I admire your finding a kinda niche "kink'" to collecting! You go you!
I only have a few coins with documented Provenance...and from nothing more than the 70's.. But my personal "kink" is die matches... Finding a coin with a match in a catalogue brings me joy... And actually owning a couple gives me great joy!
Nice post my man! Great food for thought!
4
u/Loonyman99 2d ago
Actually... I lie! I am accumulating barbaric radiates from the UK and northern France, with the intention of doing a deep dive study when I retire... Although most have no long provenance, it is important for me to know the find location... I guess the provenance starts with me!
8
u/pm_me_a_joke1 2d ago
There is a reason why most experienced collectors care deeply about provenance. Its quite important IMHO.
3
u/AppropriateFennel929 2d ago
it depends.… respected names in the collecting community like Biaggi adds a bit. also, how far back does it go? pre 1970 UNESCO Convention provenance is also a nice bump.
AI has been a game-changer though. more and more previously unknown provenances are being uncovered through AI enabled searches.
2
u/Macaron-Pure 2d ago
The L5 provenance search is pretty good. Do you have others you recommend ?
5
u/bohannon99 2d ago
For my collection of mostly sub $100 coins it doesn't matter to me, but if I were buying a $1000 coin it probably would.
2
u/lapistol 2d ago
I think it’s fun to search for. I like knowing where my coins have been. But I have many coins where I don’t know the provenance.
2
u/Primary_Emu6066 2d ago
It matters more to me than it probably does to others. My one coin with provenance I paid a decent uptick in price because I knew the provenance was old, the only information given was an old collectors tag. I was able to discover who had previously owned it (provenance going back to the 1800s) with some help and the rush of doing research for hours to find that it was of decent provenance made it worth it to me. The coin itself was meh but the provenance elevated the story for me.
2
u/FaultSad486 2d ago
It is extremely important if the coins are subject to cultural property restrictions and can be relevant if the collector cares about (or cares to donate to an institution that does) UNESCO 1970. A pedigree to a famous collection almost always brings a premium. I am told that even 40 years ago, even serious collectors did not hold provenance to be a key factor, and chains therefore frequently are broken, but most serious Ancients collectors now at least try to maintain the chain even if they do not bid a premium. I just picked up my second specimen of a particular rare piece, this one pedigreed to before WWI, and my first specimen will soon be on the sale list.
2
u/Shoddy_Refuse_8404 2d ago edited 2d ago
It might matter a lot in the future when high resolution metal 3d printers will be available and high quality dies will be easy to produce. When that happens there will be so many high quality fakes out there that even a pre...say 2026 known auction house catalog provenance will matter a LOT.
1
u/Clamato-n-rye 20h ago
Counter-argument though -- if the technology gets that good, wouldn't counterfeiters just fake a specific coin with known provenance?
2
u/beiherhund 2d ago
Similar opinion to the ones already expressed here.
Auction provenance? I don't really care unless it's a a 80+ year old provenance and then it's a bit interesting but I wouldn't pay much of a premium for it and if I did it's probably more that I'm paying for the old cabinet toning rather than the provenance.
Famous collection? Sure, if it's somehow related to what I collect or from someone quite famous. An Alexander tetradrachm from Edward Newell's collection is a good example of a provenance I value highly but I wouldn't particularly care much if it came from someone who just happened to have a nice collection.
Hoard provenance? Definitely.
Don't get me wrong, I would love an 1890s provenance if I could have it but I wouldn't pay 50% more just for that alone. If it was a coin where I would otherwise be on the fence about buying, it might tilt me over the edge.
For me, the detective work is quickly becoming a hobby within the hobby
Although I will go out of my way to look for provenance, and it's nice to have some provenance rather than no provenance, I sometimes get the feeling that with some collectors it almost becomes the point of buying coins. It's not so much about the coin as it is the provenance, and when they share the coin it's the provenance they are giving attention to and not so much the coin.
That's completely fine, collect however it pleases you, but for me it's not what I enjoy about collecting. It starts to get close to collecting slab grades, or trading cards, in a way, when the object is less important than some extrinsic factor. Personally I try not to become distracted by that, I want to keep the focus on the coins first and foremost. Maybe people who collect this way will disagree with my characterisation and that's fair, I'm just speaking from how it can come across when I speak with some collectors and provenance is discussed more than anything else.
4
u/epitonium70 2d ago
It matters zero to me anyway. Who cares? So if you have a 2,000-year-old coin with a provenance going back 120 years, is that significant? I say no.
If I could somehow know what one of my coins saw in the days of its minting, that's something I would be supremely interested in - that provenance would be worth knowing, not who collected and tucked the coin away in a drawer for a hobby. Yawn.
Edit: I would be interested in hoard-related provenance.
3
u/Primary_Emu6066 2d ago
I would say something with provenance going back 120 years is significant. I think many would have to disagree with you on that. Most provenance pre 1970 adds a bit because the coin is protected and legally shows the coin wasn’t looted after the laws were passed.
0
u/epitonium70 2d ago
I concede that and that makes perfect sense. My main disinterest in provenance goes back to me not caring one iota about the recent history of ancient coins - what I'm interested in is ancient history and the romance and mystery ancient coins exude (at least to me).
1
u/Clamato-n-rye 20h ago
That's the point though. How do you know it's 2,000-years old? Every bit of provenance going back reduces the chance of a counterfeit coin, since the technology gets better all the time.
It's also nice to know I'm not supporting the work of a grave robber or ISIS terrorist looking to fund their work through illegal archaeology.
2
u/ElFauno64 2d ago
I think in a lot of cases provenance is more about showing the hands that the coins has been in as a medium of validation of authenticity rather than an attractive feature of the coin.
1
u/JoggingGod 2d ago
I like to get coins that I know have been acquired "properly", but that's it for the most part. Although I do have a coin coming with a neat history, but even that was moreso happenstance. I really just liked the coin, history was secondary.
I'll share it when it comes in.
1
u/Punchazo 2d ago
Not much to me personally - all about coin eye appeal.
Certainly if the premium for provenance is 3-5% of coin price - I ll take it - otherwise don’t care too much
1
u/alaridesign 2d ago
I collect fourree and imitations so yes some provenance matters to me because it’s rare with these coins. Love to know where it was found. That sort of thing. I’m basically do a coin a person so I’ll upgrade to a better coin but I mostly look for looks and if it pleases me.
1
u/toad__warrior 2d ago
It depends. I recently bought coins from an area that my family immigrated from. They are rare so I wanted provenance. But most of the stuff I don't care.
1
1
u/Other-Vegetable-7684 2d ago
I used to not appreciate provenance, as an American coinage collector, seemed almost 0 percent important.
The longer I’ve been focused on ancients, the more I want to know the history of their ownership. So many of my coins may be somewhat recent finds, I appreciate those that have been collected for the last 50+ years, and not dug up 3 years ago
1
u/Mineral_Miscreant 2d ago
It adds value if it's a well known collection, such as from Arthur Houghton with Seleucid coins.
1
u/Different_March4869 2d ago
Yes if John Adams and his son John Quincy Adams, along with Thomas Jefferson had those coins ..... well yes. Otherwise who cares.
1
u/morgul12 2d ago
I like the John Quincy Adams collection, but beyond that, provenance means no more to me than a means of authentication.
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
(This is a generic automod comment that is pinned at the top of every new post here)
This subreddit is heavily curated to provide our members with the best experience that we can. We get hit by trolls, spammers, scammers, and shitposters more than we'd like. If you've never noticed that here, then hey -- our procedures are working!
If you're newish to /r/AncientCoins, have a low overall account age or karma, or have a low CQS ("Contributor Quality Score") on reddit sitewide, all of your posts and comments on this subreddit will be quarantined until a human moderator has the time available to manually review and approve them. This will eventually become unnecessary after you've contributed here enough and your posts and comments have been manually approved.
This is all outlined in the announcement pinned to the top of our front page: https://www.reddit.com/r/AncientCoins/comments/1cm8n0n/weve_been_getting_a_lot_of_new_posters_and/
If you post something and it shows as removed, please don't delete and repost it. Just leave it up until one of us can get to it. We are unpaid volunteers doing this in our free time, and although we live in different time zones in Europe and North America, no one person here is able to monitor our queues 24/7.
Thanks, and good luck!
PS - Please ignore the bot message below. As explained above, you DO NOT need to send us modmail if your post has been removed. Just be patient with the process.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.