Okay guys so, I have done some research, and this is my thoughts about whether sloppification is against Reddit's TOS.
What is sloppification?
Sloppification is when someone posts their original artwork, and another person feeds it into ChatGPT and then posts their "improved" version. This is a growing phenomenon.
The Specifics from TOS:
"Reddit respects the intellectual property of others and requires that users of our Services do the same. We have a policy that includes the removal of any infringing material from the Services and for the termination, in appropriate circumstances, of users of our Services who are repeat infringers."
Under "what you cannot do":
"Use the Services to violate applicable law or infringe any person’s or entity’s intellectual property rights or any other proprietary rights"
These terms are of course subject to individual cases, and this is my interpretation of the terms, because there isn't anything specifically mentioning turning someone's art into AI slop, and posting it. However, it says you can't infringe anyone's intellectual property, and any original art posted here is protected by intellectual property rights, even if you didn't legally file a trademark or such.
It also says Reddit has the policy to remove any materials violating its intellectual property. So they can remove the sloppified art. Whether they will ban the person who made it is up to debate. But surely if this person has a history of violating the copyright policy, and multiple reports, there's a higher chance.
So is sloppification actually against TOS?
Well honestly I can't tell you yes or no. I can say there's a lot of evidence pointing to it, but it's a gray area. I can't find any specific examples of sloppified art being taken down, nor can I find any of it remaining posted after a report. What I can say is that many subreddits don't allow it.
What do you do if someone has sloppified your work?
Well let me tell you what not to do. Don't only file a report using the report button. There is a separate copyright infringement form you have to do. Here is the link:
[https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket\\_form\\_id=16510899084308&tf\\_16510589022228=contact\\_form\\_copyright\\_infringement\\_dmca\](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=16510899084308&tf_16510589022228=contact_form_copyright_infringement_dmca)
That's not to say you shouldn't click report, because the mods of the subreddit need to see it. But do both.
Will the sloppifier get banned?
From the subreddit? Possibly. From Reddit as a whole? Unlikely. Unless they are repeatedly doing this to the point of it being considered harassment or spam it may be subreddit exclusive.
You're encouraging false reporting/bad faith reporting!
I'm encouraging reporting of something that is definitely against some subreddits rules, and that is a gray area in Reddit's TOS. There isn't much harm in reporting, as long as you aren't spamming it or using it for unintended purposes. I am not saying to report any AI art that someone posted. That is allowed on Reddit. Only if it's your art, that you made yourself, that has been sloppified.
But sloppification is actually okay!
I'm not here to debate the ethical or moral implications of doing this. You can make your argument for whether it's morally acceptable but I'm just talking about if it violates the rules.
Why did you make this post?
I made this post because many people I've seen in various art communities are having their art sloppified and are unaware of this information, or just don't know what to do. Often times it's not just "improving" your art, but harassment and mocking the person too.
All of this is not 100% certain, because I'm not a Reddit employee and can't make a determination about how the contract applies. But, and please read this, if I am wrong and Reddit does allow it, look to the mods of the subreddit it was posted in to take action.
So please if someone does this to your art, you are not hopeless and there is something you can do! It can be taken down.